
Today's Daily Mail headlines.

John Beyer, of Mediawatch UK, said: 'Youngsters act out these games. The television, film and compuer game industry cannot any longer sit on the sidelines and say this is nothing to do with us.'
Also quoted, the director of the British Board of Film Classification (which also classifies some games):
"A BBFC spokesman said: "If there were a lot of clearly-proven cases relating to a game, we would have to look at that. With Manhunt, we have one instance of a very upset parent looking to blame the game for what happened to her son. But this games has been on sale for some time - and there are no other recorded exmples of people reactiing to it by trying to copy what happens on screen."
It's an 18+ game in this instance, certificated. I'm sure kids can get away with buying copies - the paper has dug up a few instances - or they'll get pirate or borrowed versions, just as much as kids get pirate, borrowed or bought copies of 18+ films. I'm always intrigued as to how a story of one instance can influence the environment when the thousands or millions of non-news instances go unreported, i.e. the normal kids and adults playing the game who remain unaffected. Watching or reading the news is the most violence-soaked influence of all, I'd think.
So as ever, the news here isn't that games are bad per se, but that the system can break (as any system can). Kids should not be buying products aimed for 18+ adults. So when the system breaks, and when a breakable system is combined with an unstable mind, inevitably and eventually a tragic thing will happen.
But rather than waste time and money banning such games or films, fanning the flames of hysteria and unbalanced panic, would it not be better spent on media literacy, parental guidance, and a wider range of non-violent alternatives instead? Why spend all the money lining lawyer pockets and stirring up the mobs - it's such a patent waste.
The industry needs to be braver. There'll always be a place for 18+ violence, there should be no blame laid at Rockstar's feet. But more alternatives should be offered. I was in Virgin Games just the other day, and stuck for choice: too many driving and boring shooting games based on WWII (like, seven?), not enough variety, not enough story, not enough fun horror, or brave adventuring. I came out empty-handed.
This front page isn't news but what passes as news in our culture. It's humans thrilling in shlock and gore, and the Mail is no stranger to perpetuating this - except it isn't rated as 18+.
......
(Update: interesting comments follow-up on the Daily Mail site, via Malbec)
Recent Comments